As a hardcore gamer who's spent more time reeling in virtual fish than catching real ones, I've got to say—fishing minigames are the unsung heroes of gaming! Seriously, since the SNES era, every JRPG or open-world title seems to think, "Hey, why not throw in a fishing side quest?" It's become a running joke, but in 2025, it's only gotten crazier. With new tech like VR and AI integration, these minigames have evolved from simple time-wasters to immersive experiences. But here's the million-dollar question: which ones reign supreme? Well, after countless hours of casting lines and battling digital trout, I've compiled the ultimate ranking based on gameplay, immersion, and fish variety. Let's dive in! 🎮🐟

First up, why are fishing minigames so ubiquitous? It's simple—they add a chill break from all that action. Take JRPGs, for instance; they're practically built on the stuff. If you're wondering how I judged these, I looked at factors like how fun the reeling feels, whether it captures that zen vibe, and how many scaly friends you can collect. Now, onto the list—I've ranked them from good to legendary, with a dash of my own snark.

10. Tales of Arise: The JRPG Fishing Gem

top-10-fishing-minigames-in-video-games-my-2025-gamer-s-guide-image-0

Who would've thought that in 2025, I'd still be raving about this 2021 game? But Tales of Arise nails it with a twist: no annoying RNG! Instead, you press button combos to catch Kisara's 42 fish species. It's like solving a puzzle while fishing—genius, right? But why does it rank low? Honestly, it's a bit too straightforward compared to the flashier entries. Still, for JRPG purists, it's a solid start. 😊

9. Sonic Frontiers: Big's Comeback Tour

Sonic fishing? I know, I laughed too—until I saw the blue blur pulling up tires! This minigame is hilariously simple: just pass a QTE and watch the comedy unfold. In 2025, it's still a great way to grind currency, but let's be real: the gameplay is basic. Nostalgia for Big the Cat saves it, though. Would you believe Sonic's more relaxed here than in his races? 🦔

8. Dragon Ball Z: Kakarot: Goku's Fishy Fist

Watching Goku fish with his tail is pure gold! This minigame involves wiggling that prosthetic and punching fish out of water—talk about overkill. It's entertaining but falls short because, come on, there aren't enough fish varieties. As of 2025, it's a fun nostalgia trip, but I often ask: Is this more about the laughs than actual fishing? Probably. 🤣

7. Tokyo Xanadu Ex+: Arcade Gambling Madness

I'll admit, I got addicted to this one. Borrowing from Trails of Cold Steel, it adds an arcade scoring system where coins determine your luck. The more you fish, the better your odds—but it feels like gambling! In today's gaming landscape, that's risky fun. Why rank it seventh? Because the thrill comes from the gamble, not the fishing itself. Still, it's a wild ride. 🎰

6. Fire Emblem: Engage: Strategy Meets Scales

Fire Emblem adding fishing? I saw it coming! Engage's minigame is simple: hold the analog stick and mash A to reel. Money's scarce in these games, so selling fish is key. But why not higher? Well, it's repetitive, and Anna's cameo isn't enough to save it. In 2025, it's a decent distraction, but I wonder: Shouldn't a strategy series have deeper fishing? 🗡️

5. Red Dead Redemption 2: Outlaw Angler

Arthur Morgan fishing? Yep, and it's immersive! The controls prevent hand cramps—thanks, Rockstar—with L2 and R2 combos. But with only 12 fish types, it's limited. As a gamer, I appreciate the realism, but in 2025, we expect more variety. How did this become a standout? Because it fits the outlaw life perfectly. 🤠

4. Like a Dragon: Ishin: Samurai Fishing Master

The Yakuza series always delivers, and Ishin's fishing is top-notch. No RNG here—fish depend on shadow positions, making it strategic. It's addictive and fun, but why not top three? Because others have more depth. I predict: If samurai fish this well, imagine pirates in future games! 🏯

3. Final Fantasy XIV: MMO Fishing Overload

In an MMO with over a decade of updates, FFXIV's fishing is complex—mooching, double hooking, you name it. Fishing on the moon? Only here! It ranks high for variety, but as of 2025, the learning curve scares off newbies. I often think: Does this need a flowchart? Absolutely, but that's the charm. 🌕

2. Shenmue: Immersive Zen Fishing

Shenmue 3's fishing is pure relaxation with 17 spots and 20 fish types, plus realistic hours (10 AM–6 PM!). Rotate the stick fast—simple, yet immersive. Why not number one? Because it lacks excitement; it's all about the vibe. In today's fast-paced world, it's a breath of fresh air. 🌸

1. Final Fantasy XV: The Undisputed King

Drumroll, please! FFXV wins with 109 fish species, QTEs, and deep mechanics. It's not a minigame—it's a whole fishing RPG! Why top? Because it's addictive and expansive. As of 2025, it's still the gold standard. I bet: With new tech, future games might top this, but for now, Noctis reigns supreme. 👑

People Also Ask: Quick Q&A

Ever wondered about fishing minigames? Here are some burning questions:

  • Why do so many games include fishing? It's a stress-reliever—perfect for breaks from combat. Plus, devs love adding quirky side activities.

  • Is fishing minigames just a trend? Nope! As of 2025, they're evolving with VR and AI, making them more realistic and fun.

  • Can fishing ruin a game? Sometimes—if it's poorly designed, it feels tacked-on. But when done right, like in FFXV, it enhances the experience.

  • What's the hardest fish to catch? In FFXIV, some require insane timing—good luck without a guide! 🎣

My Personal Future Outlook

Looking ahead to 2026 and beyond, I'm psyched about where fishing minigames are headed. With advancements in haptic feedback and VR, I predict we'll see full-blown fishing sims within games—imagine feeling the tug on a controller or casting a line in virtual reality! As a gamer, I hope developers keep innovating, maybe even adding co-op fishing modes. But let's be honest, will anything ever dethrone FFXV? Probably not anytime soon—it set the bar sky-high. Until then, happy fishing, folks! 🚀🐠

In summary, fishing minigames are more than just filler; they're a testament to gaming's creativity. From Tales of Arise's button puzzles to FFXV's epic scale, each entry brings something unique. So next time you're in a game, take a break and cast a line—you might just reel in some fun! 😄